Methodology · Last updated 15 November 2026
How we rate software
App Advisor never blends everything into one star rating. Each product shows four separate indicators: the AppAdvisor Editorial Score, a Feature & Functionality Score, an India Business Suitability Score and, only when verified buyers have reviewed it, a Verified Customer Rating. The first three are our assessments, not customer satisfaction.
The four indicators at a glance
AppAdvisor Editorial Score
0–10Our editorial assessment of pricing transparency, popularity, India readiness and company maturity. Every listed product has one.
Always shown
Feature & Functionality Score
0–10How much of the category's core capability checklist the vendor documents, plus module breadth and platform reach.
"Not yet assessed" until we hold a source-checked profile
India Business Suitability Score
0–10Documented India signals only: GST, Tally, INR pricing, payroll compliance, UPI, Indian languages, India hosting, local support, Made in India.
"Not yet assessed" when there is not enough documented data
Verified Customer Rating
1–5 starsThe average of reviews written on App Advisor by verified users, shown with the number of reviews. Never imported from other sites.
"No verified reviews yet" until the first review is approved
They are never added together, averaged or merged. Editorial, feature and India scores are App Advisor assessments: they are not customer satisfaction and are never shown as star ratings or published as rating structured data.
1. AppAdvisor Editorial Score (0–10)
The original App Advisor formula, renamed so nobody mistakes it for a user rating. Each signal is scored 0–10 and weighted:
| Signal | Weight | How it is scored |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing transparency | 35% | Completely free 10, free plan with paid tiers 9, published subscription price 7.5, quote-only or unpublished price 4. |
| Popularity | 30% | Position in our editorial adoption ranking within the category (how widely the product is used and searched in India), scaled from 40 to 100. Products built outside India lose 3 points and 40 very widely adopted products on our editorial reference list gain 8. Never a review count, never paid. |
| India readiness | 20% | Built in India 10; GST, e-invoicing or TDS named in the product's own description 7; any other product 5.5. |
| Company maturity | 15% | 4 points plus 0.3 for every year since the product was founded, capped at 10 (8 years is assumed when the founding year is unknown). |
Consumer apps (UPI, shopping, entertainment and similar) lose 1.2 points so they do not crowd business software out of rankings.
Limitations. The editorial score rewards published pricing: a weak product with transparent pricing can outrank a strong product that only quotes on request. That is exactly why it is shown next to the Feature & Functionality Score and never on its own as “the” rating. It also measures popularity, which favours established products over good new ones.
2. Feature & Functionality Score (0–10)
We measure what the vendor documents against the capability checklist for the product's primary category: 70% checklist coverage, 15% module breadth (documented feature groups, up to five, and feature items, up to 25) and 15% platform reach (mobile apps, named integrations up to eight, and an API or webhooks). A capability counts only when it is stated affirmatively in our source-checked profile; caveats such as “not available on the free plan” never count.
Billing, GST & POS10 checks+
Applies to: Billing software, Invoicing software, GST software, POS & retail billing.
- GST invoices with HSN/SAC codes
- E-invoicing (IRN) and e-way bills
- Fast POS or counter billing
- UPI, QR and online payment collection
- Payment reminders and receivables
- Quotes, estimates and credit/debit notes
- Stock and item master (barcode, batch, variants)
- GST returns and tax reports
- Tally export or accounting sync
- Multi-user, multi-branch or multi-GSTIN
Accounting & Finance10 checks+
Applies to: Accounting software.
- Double-entry ledgers and trial balance
- GST returns and reconciliation
- E-invoicing and e-way bills
- Bank feeds and reconciliation
- TDS and TCS
- Balance sheet, P&L and cash flow
- Invoicing, bills and payables
- Multi-company, branch or currency
- Audit trail and edit log
- Accountant (CA) access and user roles
CRM & Sales10 checks+
Applies to: CRM software, Dialer & telecalling CRM, Sales engagement & dialler software, Field sales & SFA software, AI sales agents & agentic CRM, Real estate CRM, Education & admissions CRM, Insurance, lending & banking CRM, Healthcare & clinic CRM.
- Lead capture from web, ads and marketplaces
- Pipeline stages and deal tracking
- Lead assignment and routing
- Tasks, follow-ups and reminders
- Calling, dialler and call logs
- Email, WhatsApp and SMS from the CRM
- Workflow automation
- Quotes, proposals and orders
- Reports, forecasts and dashboards
- Custom fields, modules and pipelines
HRMS & Payroll10 checks+
Applies to: HRMS software, Payroll software.
- Employee records and documents
- Attendance, shifts and biometric or geo check-in
- Leave and holiday policies
- Payroll processing and payslips
- Statutory compliance (PF, ESI, PT, TDS)
- Onboarding and exit (full & final)
- Performance, goals and OKRs
- Employee self-service portal or app
- Expense claims and reimbursements
- Recruitment and hiring
Inventory & ERP10 checks+
Applies to: Inventory software, ERP software, Warehouse management (WMS).
- Multi-location and warehouse stock
- Barcode, batch, expiry and serial tracking
- Purchase orders and reorder points
- Sales orders, invoicing and dispatch
- Stock valuation, audits and adjustments
- Accounting, GST and finance
- Production, BOM and manufacturing
- Marketplace and e-commerce sync
- Quality checks and returns
- Reports, MIS and dashboards
Marketing Automation10 checks+
Applies to: Marketing automation, Email marketing software, WhatsApp automation.
- Segmentation and audiences
- Journeys and automated flows
- Email campaigns
- WhatsApp and SMS campaigns
- Push and in-app messaging
- Personalisation and dynamic content
- A/B testing and optimisation
- Forms, pop-ups and landing pages
- Lead scoring and CRM sync
- Analytics and attribution
General business software8 checks+
Applies to every other category.
- Reports and dashboards
- Workflow automation and approvals
- User roles and permissions
- Import, export and data migration
- Security controls (SSO, 2FA, encryption)
- Alerts and notifications
- Customisation and templates
- AI assistance
Limitations. The score measures documented breadth, not depth or quality: two products that both “have payroll” can differ hugely, and that is what demos are for. Vendors that document less score lower until they publish more. Checklists differ by category, so compare feature scores within a category only. Today 571 products have a feature score; the rest show “Not yet assessed” until we complete a source-checked profile with at least 10 documented capabilities.
3. India Business Suitability Score (0–10)
Built from documented signals only. A signal that does not apply to the product's category is left out of the calculation instead of counting against it, and the score is the weighted share of applicable signals the vendor documents.
| Signal | Weight | Counts for | Credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| GST, e-invoicing and e-way bills | 20 | Billing, accounting, inventory and ERP, and other money-handling categories (finance, operations, industry software) | GST support alone earns 60%; e-invoicing or e-way bills earn full credit. |
| Tally integration, import or export | 10 | Billing, accounting, inventory and ERP, HRMS and payroll, and other money-handling categories | Full credit or none. |
| Prices published in rupees (INR) | 15 | Every product | Published INR prices or a free product earn full credit; INR quotes without a published price, or INR billing mentioned for a USD price list, earn 50%. |
| Indian payroll compliance (PF, ESI, PT, TDS/Form 16, LWF, gratuity) | 20 | HRMS and payroll | 25% for each statutory item documented, up to 100% at four. |
| UPI or Indian payment gateways | 10 | Billing, accounting, inventory and ERP, and other money-handling categories | Full credit or none. |
| Indian-language interface or support | 10 | Every product | One Indian language earns 75%; two or more earn full credit. |
| Data hosted in India | 10 | Cloud products (not desktop-only software, where your data stays on your own machine) | Full credit or none. |
| Local support (Indian phone line, IST hours, Indian offices or on-site help) | 10 | Every product | Full credit or none. |
| Made in India | 10 | Every product | Full credit or none. |
Limitations. A missing signal means we did not find it documented on the vendor's site, not that the product cannot do it. Vendors can send us the official page and we re-check. Products without enough documented India information show “Not yet assessed”; today 592 products have an India score.
4. Verified Customer Rating (1–5 stars)
The only customer-satisfaction number on App Advisor. It is the average of reviews written on App Advisor by verified users and approved by moderation, always shown with the number of reviews. We never borrow ratings from app stores or other review sites and never fabricate reviews. Until a product has its first approved review it shows “No verified reviews yet” with a link to write one. This is also the only rating we publish as structured data (AggregateRating) for search engines.
Source-checked and Vendor-verified
- Source-checked means App Advisor checked the facts (pricing, features, India details) against the vendor's official website, and we show the date we checked. Most listings are source-checked.
- Vendor-verified appears only on listings the vendor has claimed and confirmed. It is a statement about who confirmed the facts, never about quality, and it does not change any score.
How sorting works
Category lists default to the AppAdvisor Editorial Score, with Made in India products listed first. You can re-sort by Feature score or India suitability; products not yet assessed go to the end. No sort order can be bought.
Editorial tags
Recommended marks the top three products in a category by editorial score. Trending marks fast-rising products founded in the last eight years. New marks products founded in the last three years. AI powered, Made in India, Free plan, Open source, GST ready and Mobile app come from the vendor's own published facts. Sponsored marks paid placements and is always labelled.
Spotted a wrong fact? Report the listing and we will re-check it against the vendor's official site.
Questions
Is the AppAdvisor Editorial Score a customer rating?+
No. It is our editorial assessment of pricing transparency, popularity, India readiness and company maturity. It says nothing about how satisfied customers are. Customer satisfaction appears only as the Verified Customer Rating, from reviews written on App Advisor.
Why do you show four scores instead of one?+
A single blended number hides trade-offs. With the old single rating, a weak product with published pricing could outrank a strong product that only quotes on request. Showing the scores side by side lets you weigh transparency, features, India fit and real customer experience yourself.
Why does a product say "Not yet assessed"?+
Feature and India scores need a source-checked profile: facts we have checked on the vendor's official website. Feature scores also need at least 10 documented capabilities. We would rather show nothing than guess.
Can a vendor pay for a better score or position?+
No. Sponsored placements are labelled "Sponsored" and never change any score or the default order. A vendor can improve its Feature or India score only by documenting real capabilities on its official website, which we then check.
Can I compare feature scores across categories?+
Not meaningfully. Each category has its own checklist, so 7/10 for a CRM and 7/10 for billing software measure different things. Compare feature scores within a category.
Where do the verified customer ratings in search results come from?+
Only from reviews submitted on App Advisor and approved by moderation. It is the only score we publish as rating structured data for search engines. Editorial, feature and India scores are never published as ratings.